|
Apparently
big business isn't hip. While the musings and theories of
Marshall McLuhan, Noam Chomsky, et al. have been around for
a while, it took Michael Moore to bring such ideas out of
academic print runs and unto the masses. Mark Achbar and Jennifer
Abbott's The Corporation is another strike against
suits, board room meetings and the brands and chain stores
we know we should hate but we use anyway.
In
the eyes of the law, corporations are seen as people. It's
true. This is the angle The Corporation takes as it
attempts to uncover some of big business' dirty little secrets.
Combining interviews with a broad mix of front-line experts
and outside thinkers with plenty ironic stock footage from
Mrs. Applebottom's 16mm collection of instructional films
last viewed by the Class of 1958, The Corporation succeeds
on likely its most important front: it's entertaining.
The
film spends a long time listing off a broad mix of problems
and social injustices people around the world face when dealing
with multi-billion-dollar corporations. A long time. Coming
from many angles, by the time it's all over, you'd think ole'
Satan himself is but a pawn in the corporate machine. The
Corporation makes itself legitimate by crisscrossing North
America to gather comments from leading scholars and business
leaders. Achbar and Abbott are also worshipers from the Church
of Chomsky, Moore and Naomi Klein, the leading living voices
in the fight against skyscraper dwellers. Moore steals the
show with his colourful commentary that, as usual is spot
on in pinpointing many of the reasons we sheep are as we are
and how we're seduced by it all. But for all the corporate
bashing, there is very little of the other side that is allowed
to say anything. Those who are given any significant amount
of screen time are presented in a very ironic tone. One such
example is poor Andrea Finger, a PR rep for Disney's surreal
venture into real estate, Celebration, Florida. It's a town
run by Disney. As she's talking about the values the town
promotes, the screen shows children playing in a street filled
with fake 'snow', which in fact looks more like a mass dumping
of shaving cream. Now that's healthy.
On
the rare occasions that the enemy is actually given a chance
to defend themselves, Achbar and Abbott cut them off before
they can actually get a potentially meaningful statement in.
After doing a segment on the connections of IBM and Hitler's
Third Reich during WWII, there are some very strong accusations
made. Irving Wladawsky-Berger, a high-ranking official within
IBM, says that there is evidence that refutes this claim.
Rather than allowing him to present his facts in full, the
film quickly cuts to more damaging information that further
ties IBM into the holocaust, whether they knew it or not.
Allowing Wladawsky-Berger and others to tell the other side
of the story would have certainly given some balance to The
Corporation. Some could argue that the corporations have
been just as one-sided and now it's time to hear something
different. But by using the eye-for-an-eye approach brings
the filmmakers closer to their enemies than it does setting
themselves apart.
There
are so many stories and examples in The Corporation
that I think it would have ultimately been better served as,
at the very least, a miniseries if not an ongoing television
program. Was it considered or could it have happened? I don't
know. But as the film stands, it glosses over so much that
by the end I was overwhelmed by it all. Sure, I felt guilty
for my choice of footwear and was angry about all the 'bad'
things I do as a mass consumer, but what are the alternatives?
About
once a week, I like to eat at McDonald's. I know full well
what it's doing to my body, how they treat their workers and
about some of the things they pump into their food. I also
wear Nike runners and I even occasionally shop at Wal-Mart.
I know they're evil too. I've heard it before and I'll hear
it again. What I want is for someone to tell what I can do
about it. The Corporation spends almost two-and-a-half
hours exposing just a taste of all the bad things some of
these companies are doing and the things they do to protect
themselves. The film spends about one sentence encouraging
its viewers to do something about it, and even then it's only
in a vague ra-ra comment from Moore at the very end of the
film. A visit to the film's website does provide some links
that might act as starting points to take action, but that's
only useful if you have the Internet (if you're reading this
review, my guess is that you do). There's no momentum to act
though after the film ends, though. Those there watching it
with me seemed ready to act too. Between The Corporation,
Moore's body of work and such books as No Logo and
Fast Food Nation, there's plenty of interest in making
the world a better place. But what we need more than ever
isn't another exposé on the ills of business but rather
someone to actually lead the charge.
©Movie
Views; May 1, 2004
|
|
 |
| Mark
Achbar |
| Jennifer
Abbott |
 |
| Joel
Bakan |
|
Harold Crooks |
 |
| Michael
Moore |
| Noam
Chomsky |
| Naomi
Klein |
| Jane
Akre |
|
Ray Anderson |
 |
| 2004 |
 |
| Canada |
 |
| 145
minutes |
| |
|